Ex player return poll

[Cjay]

Always get whispers of an ex player returning in the summer.

Regardless of whether it's likely or possible

So how about 3 of our Championship stars.

Manor Solomon
Crycensio Summerville
Georginio Rutter

All theoretically possible in a way maybe to a degree.

Solomon hasn't had the best loan spells this season so unlikely perhaps he will make the move permanent and unlikely Spurs want him back.

Summerville of course with West Ham having the very real threat of relegation, he isn't staying if they are.

And Rutter has found his starts slightly limited at times for one reason or another.

And unlikely of course because.

Solomon may have other offers, he wasn't either keen or asked to return before.

Summerville does have interest from much richer clubs, lots of them.

Rutter cost Brighton a fortune and are never going to sell cheap and hasn't performed so badly Brighton are likely keen for a sale.

But if the opportunity arose.

Who would you want back if any and why?

[Johnthewhite]

Not for me, going back is quite often a step back imo.
Solomon is no better than Okafor in my view.

Summerville has a tendency to go missing, particularly in big matches and a bit of a one trick pony, again in my view.

Rutter is probably the only one you could put a case forward for as he is yet to reach his ceiling. However it would still be a no from me.

[Barlow Boy]

Never go back in life, so it’s a no for any returning player for me.

[Jaydog]

None.
But players do come back and can be of assistance maybe later in their careers like Byram for example

[The Subhuman]

I want two votes ... but Cry is Leeds, get him back we have a Summerville shaped hole in the team

[The Subhuman]

No Archie?

[Cjay]

No Archie?

Absolutely no chance of that I felt.

He's young, talented and home grown, hed go for an absolute fortune if Spurs went down.

[pjm2019]

Manor Solomon - Yes for £10m and £30K wages per week
Crycensio Summerville - yes for £15m and £30K wages per week
Georginio Rutter - Yes for £20M and £30K wages per week
Archie Gray - yes for £15m and £35K wages per week

[The Subhuman]

Manor Solomon - Yes for £10m and £30K wages per week
Crycensio Summerville - yes for £15m and £30K wages per week
Georginio Rutter - Yes for £20M and £30K wages per week
Archie Gray - yes for £15m and £35K wages per week

30k a week is championship wages and just wrong in the prem, Just say you don't want any of them. I'm fine with that.

[CUSSIE01]

Manor Solomon - Yes for £10m and £30K wages per week
Crycensio Summerville - yes for £15m and £30K wages per week
Georginio Rutter - Yes for £20M and £30K wages per week
Archie Gray - yes for £15m and £35K wages per week

Georginio got a brilliant reception from the fans when he was warming up and then coming on & then gave the fans a wave after the game. Class act.

[The Subhuman]

Georginio got a brilliant reception from the fans when he was warming up and then coming on & then gave the fans a wave after the game. Class act.

I loved the first thing he did was go chat to Joe then go find Ethan .... I reckon he said to Joe "Go easy mate, I wanna look good to the manager"

[whiteswan]

I want two votes ... but Cry is Leeds, get him back we have a Summerville shaped hole in the team

You can have my vote faaip...

[BlackHillsPaul]

I voted for NONE. We are going to need better players added to our squad, particularly in the attacking areas if we are to be successful. I've seen what these players can do in the Premier League. We will need to do better....

[YorkshireSquare]

How many players has coming back actually worked for?

Frank Gray, John Lukic, David Batty

[The Subhuman]

How many players has coming back actually worked for?

Frank Gray, John Lukic, David Batty

How many have there been and what's the reason for the return. You could call Byram a success, he came back as quality depth and provided that

[Carrick Dave]

I've gone for none because we don't need wingers the way we play now, and we need a more specialized creator than Geo behind DCL going forward.

May change next season, who knows.

[YorkshireSquare]

How many have there been and what's the reason for the return. You could call Byram a success, he came back as quality depth and provided that

Other players are;

Ian Baird, Sam Byram , Alex Cairns, Lee Chapman (loan), John Charles, Wilf Copping, Brian Deane (loan), Fabian Delph (loan), Andy Gray, Peter Lorimer

Not counting Jack Clarke who was loaned straight back and Michael Gray who had two loan spells.

[The Subhuman]

Other players are;

Ian Baird, Sam Byram , Alex Cairns, Lee Chapman (loan), John Charles, Wilf Copping, Brian Deane (loan), Fabian Delph (loan), Andy Gray, Peter Lorimer

Not counting Jack Clarke who was loaned straight back and Michael Gray who had two loan spells.

I'd say Byram and Cairns have been successes, never saw Charles play, nor Copping. Seem to recall Deane having a decent second spell, wasn't Delph injured a lot second time round. Lorimer was headed toward his 40's second time around.. Still 17 goals in 76 "appearances"

So I think we've had a fairly successful time with players coming back and in this case Geo/Gray or Cry would all still be before peak years. Usually you get them back in their declining years

[Pullhard]

I went for none. Think we could get more bang for our buck elsewhere.
Jimmy and Solomon certainly don’t fit the Big B******s FC profile

[Victor_OTT_17]

Archie Gray only for me. Solomon snubbed us, Summerville left for peanuts cos the grass was greener and we broke even on Rutter but he wanted to go anyway. I'm a great believer in if they don't wanna be here: get rid!