Player Ratings vs Palace (a)

[1964white]

Plus any individual analysis

10 - Out of this World
9 - Excellent
8 - Very Good
7 -Good
6 - Average
5 - Below Par
4 - Poor
3 - Abysmal
2 - Worse than very bad
1 - May as well stayed at home

[The Subhuman]

Darlow - 7.5
Justin - 7
Gudmundsson - 5 - sent off
Ampadu - 7.5
Rodon - 9
Bijol - 5.5
Struijk - 8.5
Stach - 8.5
Aaronson - 5.5 - sub
Calvert Lewin - 6.5
Nmecha - 6 - sub

Gruev - 7
Bogle - 7

[Cowboy Dan]

Darlow - 6
Justin - 7
Gudmundsson - 6
Ampadu - 8
Rodon - 9
Bijol - 7
Struijk - 8
Stach - 8
Aaronson - 5
Calvert Lewin - 5
Nmecha - 6

Gruev - 7
Bogle - 5

[The Subhuman]

Have I over rated Darlow? Not like me, but thought he had a decent game and we got one very good goal saving save. OK marked down for the lax play early but good game overall

People do realise the goal stands if the initial save is not made?

not so much this thread yet but the MOTM I expected to see him in most top sixes

[1964white]

Have I over rated Darlow? Not like me, but thought he had a decent game and we got one very good goal saving save. OK marked down for the lax play early but good game overall

People do realise the goal stands if the initial save is not made?

not so much this thread yet but the MOTM I expected to see him in most top sixes

A pass from KD, and two passes later we were in a decent offensive position.

Four saves in all including the magnificent stop onto the bar.

[Cowboy Dan]

Have I over rated Darlow? Not like me, but thought he had a decent game and we got one very good goal saving save. OK marked down for the lax play early but good game overall

People do realise the goal stands if the initial save is not made?

not so much this thread yet but the MOTM I expected to see him in most top sixes

Darlow didn't have anything to do; his only contributions were saving that deflection that was going wide and nearly giving the ball away early on. It was Johnson who crossed the ball who was offside, so would have been ruled out anyway.

[The Subhuman]

Darlow didn't have anything to do; his only contributions were saving that deflection that was going wide and nearly giving the ball away early on. It was Johnson who crossed the ball who was offside, so would have been ruled out anyway.

You're correct now I've seen it again

[1964white]

7 Darlow
7 Justin
5 Gudmundsson
8 Ampadu
9 Rodon
7 Bijol
8 Struijk
8 Stach
4 Aaronson
4 Nmecha
7 Calvert Lewin
Subs
7 Gruev
5 Bogle

[1964white]

Bump

[Tyzy]

Darlow - 6
Justin - 6
Gudmundsson - 5
Ampadu - 6
Rodon - 7
Bijol - 5
Struijk - 6
Stach - 7
Aaronson - 5
Calvert Lewin - 6
Nmecha - 6

Gruev - 5
Bogle - 6

[CUSSIE01]

Darlow - 6.5
Justin - 7
Gudmundsson - 5.5
Ampadu - 8
Rodon - 8.5
Bijol - 6
Struijk - 8
Stach - 8.5
Aaronson - 5.5
Calvert Lewin - 6.5
Nmecha - 6

Gruev - 7
Bogle - 6.5

[John in Louisiana]

Darlow - 7
Justin - 7
Gudmundsson - 5
Ampadu - 8
Rodon - 9 Best player on the pitch by a wide margin.
Bijol - 7
Struijk - 8
Stach - 8
Aaronson - 5
Calvert Lewin - 6
Nmecha - 5.5

Gruev - 7
Bogle - 5

[Jammy 07]

Darlow 7
Justin 7.5
Rodon 8
Bijol 7.5
Struijk 7.5
Gudmundsson 6.5 (was playing well and the referee was an idiot)
Ampedu 8
Stach 8
Aaronson 6.5
DCL 7 ( missed pen otherwise a higher score)
Nmecha 7

Bogle 6.5
Gruev 7

[JoeDenver]

Darlow - 7
Justin - 6.5
Gudmundsson - 5.5 (unlucky to be sent off)
Ampadu - 7
Rodon - 8.5 (warrior performance from Joe)
Bijol - 6.5 (would’ve been higher if it wasn’t for the stupid yellow)
Struijk - 8.5 (see Rodon…great performance from Pascal)
Stach - 7.5
Aaronson - 6 (thought he did some good things, but don’t fault him being subbed after Guds was sent off)
Calvert Lewin - 6 (pen miss keeps his performance at a 6)
Nmecha - 5.5 (quiet from him)

Gruev - 7.5 (great game from Gruev, who I can be critical of)
Bogle - 6

[The Subhuman]

What I love about Pascal is he doesn't hide, even if there's a high chance of a f**k up he'll just go for it.. Rodon, a little bit and Bijol, go missing at times

[1964white]

What I love about Pascal is he doesn't hide, even if there's a high chance of a f**k up he'll just go for it.. Rodon, a little bit and Bijol, go missing at times

Rodon & Struijk have adapted to the Premier League fantastically well

Top 4 current season average ratings
7.6 Rodon
7.5 Stach
7.3 Struijk
7.0 Ampadu

These four are generally our most consistent performers.

[YorkshireSquare]

Been playing with a system for voting...

https://motforum.com/data/ratings.php?match=4843


What's everyones thoughts? I like the idea of it but I also like the idea of seeing everyones scores in a seperate post, generates more debate.

[DDB220]

Been playing with a system for voting...

https://motforum.com/data/ratings.php?match=4843


What's everyones thoughts? I like the idea of it but I also like the idea of seeing everyones scores in a seperate post, generates more debate.

You really are pushing out the algorithms. Can you add two zero’s on the end - asking for a friend who marks performances differently.

[1964white]

Been playing with a system for voting...

https://motforum.com/data/ratings.php?match=4843


What's everyones thoughts? I like the idea of it but I also like the idea of seeing everyones scores in a seperate post, generates more debate.

I like the idea, Adam.

[YorkshireSquare]

I like the idea, Adam.

Ok, I've amended now.

Just a test this time as people have already voted, but if we have a spreadsheet of the ratings for each player for each game I can feed them into the system. Totals then appear on the match page and the season summary page.

https://motforum.com/stats/match/4843/
https://motforum.com/stats/season/detail/2025-2026/